You are hereForums / Issues / Other Issues / Stand Your Ground (if you are a white male)
Stand Your Ground (if you are a white male)
With the strenth of the gun lobby, I don't expect the "Stand Your Ground" laws to be weakened or disolved in a anyway. In fact, sadly, more states will likely adopt them. The weakness of the law is apparent in the Treyvon Martin case, but I have also heard of some other cases where the law does not seem to help much if you are not a white male. Having a great interest in criminal justice as it applies to minorities, I would really like to know how many successful "stand your ground" defenses involve white males vs. minority defendents. I was absolutely shocked at the below case and thought it was worth sharing. This woman got 20 years and nobody was harmed while Zimmerman may walk?
A Florida mother was sentenced to 20 years in prison for firing warning shots at her abusive husband. A protective order was in place against him. Just contrast that with how George Zimmerman was treated after killing someone. I guess in Florida, standing your ground doesn't apply to women who are victims of domestic violence. She's black and a woman, which explains everything.
(CBS News) JACKSONVILLE, Fla. - A Florida woman who fired warning shots against her allegedly abusive husband has been sentenced to 20 years in prison.
Marissa Alexander of Jacksonville had said the state's "Stand Your Ground" law should apply to her because she was defending herself against her allegedly abusive husband when she fired warning shots inside her home in August 2010. She told police it was to escape a brutal beating by her husband, against whom she had already taken out a protective order.
CBS Affiliate WETV reports that Circuit Court Judge James Daniel handed down the sentence Friday.
Under Florida's mandatory minimum sentencing requirements Alexander could not receive a lesser sentence, even though she has never been in trouble with the law before. Judge Daniel said the law did not allow for extenuating or mitigating circumstances to reduce the sentence below the 20-year minimum.
"I really was crying in there," Marissa's 11-year-old daughter told WETV. "I didn't want to cry in court, but I just really feel hurt. I don't think this should have been happening."
Alexander was convicted of attempted murder after she rejected a plea deal for a three-year prison sentence. She said she did not believe she did anything wrong.
She was recently denied a new trial after appealing to the judge to reconsider her case based on Florida's controversial "Stand Your Ground" law. The law states that the victim of a crime does not have to attempt to run for safety and can immediately retaliate in self-defense.
Alexander's attorney said she was clearly defending herself and should not have to spend the next two decades behind bars.
Alexander's case has drawn support from domestic abuse advocates - and comparison to the case of neighborhood watch volunteer George Zimmerman, who has claimed a "Stand Your Ground" defense in his fatal shooting of Florida teenager Trayvon Martin.


This is absolutely sickening!--- My heart is broken for this wonderful lady! She never had a criminal record; she is college educated and the mother of three beautiful children. She was a victim of Domestic Violence and now she is a victim of the system!! ---Incredible. A white Hispanic male kills a black child and he is out awaiting when or if a trial will be set. An African American mother, who only fired a warning shot in the air is convicted of attempted murder and got 20 years!! this is insane!!- i am glad to see this issue posted on this site!--- Hopefully, more people will take notice and get involved because this is complete madness!!.
This is absolutely sickening!--- My heart is broken for this wonderful lady! She never had a criminal record; she is college educated and the mother of three beautiful children. She was a victim of Domestic Violence and now she is a victim of the system!! ---Incredible. A white Hispanic male kills a black child and he is out awaiting when or if a trial will be set. An African American mother, who only fired a warning shot in the air is convicted of attempted murder and got 20 years!! this is insane!!- i am glad to see this issue posted on this site!--- Hopefully, more people will take notice and get involved because this is complete madness!!.
Congresswoman Corrine Brown is trying to help and bring attention to this case. I hope it gets extensive media coverage. This is a terrible injustice, to say the least. Sounds like Brown is also doing the reserarch I eluded to, finding out how the Stand Your Ground law impacts minorities vs. how it helps white males. I am very interested in that data.
Congresswoman Corrine Brown Deplores Marissa Alexander Ruling (Washington, DC) Congresswoman Brown made the following statement: Earlier today, I watched in horror and extreme sadness as a judge sentenced Marissa Alexander, a documented victim of domestic violence, to a mandatory minimum of 20 years in prison for firing warning shot into the air after she was attacked by her husband. This African American woman didn’t hurt anyone and now she might not hug her children for twenty years.
The imbalance in this case was abundantly clear in the courtroom. On the State’s Attorney side of the room, I saw nine prosecutors and twenty officers. On Marissa’s side, I saw a lone defense attorney doing his best in what clearly an unfair fight. My first step in this case will be to bring in the nation’s best experts in domestic violence law. The Florida criminal justice system has sent two clear messages today. One is that if women who are victims of domestic violence try to protect themselves, the “Stand Your Ground Law” will not apply to them. Just minutes before the incident, Marissa’s husband told her “if I can't have you, nobody going to have you.” Millions of abused women have heard those words. Abused women like Marissa, who has a master’s degree and no prior record, need support and counseling so they don’t find themselves in these situations to begin with.
Arresting and prosecuting them when no one was hurt does not help anyone. Even worse, mandatory minimum sentences just make the system appear arbitrary and cruel. The second message is that if you are black, the system will treat you differently. A mere fifty miles away in Sanford Florida, a white man who shot a black teenager and claimed self-defense was not even arrest until community leaders and people around the world expressed their outrage. I have spoken to countless lawyers and they have yet to discover any cases in Florida where an African American was able to successfully use the “Stand Your Ground Law” defense in a hearing.” Another step I will take is to call for a study into racial disparities in the application of this law. What I didn’t see in the courtroom today is mercy or justice. The three year plea deal from Angela Corey is not mercy and a mandatory twenty year sentence is not justice. I hope that the people will come to Marissa’s defense as the system has so utterly failed her. This is just the beginning, not the end.
Kelly thank you for bringing attention to this. The only way change can happen is that the spot light is shined on these terrible issues!! -- My heart really goes out to this lovey lady!! I would love to see the studies relative to the "Stand Your Ground law" and its application to African Americans